Mario's Pizza

Discover Mario's Pizza in Port Ewen, NY, your favorite local spot for authentic NY-style pizza, cauliflower and gluten-free options, hearty meatball subs, Philly cheesesteak pies, and delicious Italian dishes. Family-owned and loved by the community.

Welcome to Mario's Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza

Located at 186 Broadway in Port Ewen, Mario's Pizza serves up classic Italian dishes with a twist. This family-owned spot is a favorite among locals, known for its fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. Whether you crave a slice of New York-style pizza or a hearty meatball parm sub, the extensive menu caters to every appetite. Gluten-free options offer inclusivity for those with dietary needs. A bustling atmosphere fills the air most evenings, especially on busy Tuesdays at 5 PM.

With over 100 dishes from appetizers to desserts, every meal here feels like a feast.

Mario's combines tradition with community spirit. The inviting vibe welcomes families and friends to gather and enjoy quality food together. Each dish reflects the owners' passion for Italy's culinary heritage, ensuring every bite is memorable. Pizza lovers can indulge in unique options like cauliflower crust without compromising taste, while hearty eaters can dive into specialty pies like the Philly cheese steak.

Mario's Pizza boasts an impressive array of features that elevate the dining experience. With 102 menu items, every visit can bring a new discovery. The restaurant specializes not only in pizza but also in a wide variety of subs, calzones, and classic Italian dinners. Popular items include generous mozzarella sticks, savory stuffed shells, and delightful cheesecake, making it a haven for food lovers.

The ambience draws in patrons with its cozy setting and friendly staff.

Regulars often find themselves returning for the excellent service and comfortable dining area. For those on the go, pizza by the slice offers a quick and delicious meal, while families can share large deluxe pizzas, ideal for a group feast.

Weekly specials and family-friendly promotions create a warm community feel, encouraging bonding over good food. The busiest times illustrate its popularity, especially on Tuesday evenings, demonstrating how integral this eatery is to the Port Ewen dining scene.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

186 Broadway, Port Ewen, NY 12466, United States

Phone

+1 845-338-1157

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza
Mario's Pizza

Mario's Pizza stands as a hallmark in the Port Ewen community. Over the years, this establishment has embraced its family roots while evolving into a culinary hotspot. Locals cherish the commitment to high-quality, homemade Italian food. Each pizza crust is crafted carefully, using fresh ingredients to get a rich, flavorful base. One of the standout offerings is the cauliflower pizza, showcasing innovation while staying true to traditional pizza-making methods and catering to healthier lifestyles.

The business thrives on its relationships with patrons, who often feel like part of the family by sharing meals during special gatherings or regular nights out.

The owners listen to feedback, constantly honing flavors and expanding the menu based on community preferences. It’s common to find customers chatting at the counter, discussing flavors or sharing recommendations from the extensive menu. This focus on community building has earned Mario's Pizza a loyal customer base, exemplifying the essence of a local eatery.

Visitors can expect warmth and sincerity that extend beyond the dining table. Known for exceeding expectations, Mario's commitment to customer satisfaction guarantees a delightful experience.

From the homemade sauces to the hand-tossed crusts, every detail reflects a philosophy of quality and care. The ambiance radiates an inviting charm that makes it ideal for family dinners, late-night cravings, or casual hangouts with friends. With each bite, guests can connect with the rich Italian heritage brought forth by the owners, who pour their heart into every dish.

Mario's Pizza

The exterior of Mario's Pizza showcases a quaint charm befitting its location on Broadway. The warm tones of the building make it an inviting sight for passersby. The simple sign above the door hints at the deliciousness within. The outdoor seating area allows guests to enjoy their meals while soaking in the small-town atmosphere. On pleasant days, this spot becomes a favorite for enjoying a slice under the open sky.

Inside, the vibe is lively yet casual, perfect for families and friends coming together for a hearty meal. The walls often feature photos depicting Italian culture, enhancing the cozy dining experience and providing a touch of authenticity.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday4-9 PM
  • Monday11:30 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11:30 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11:30 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11:30 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11:30 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11:30 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We were just passing through this town and decided to grab some pizza on the way. Honestly, we weren't expecting much, but wow, were we surprised! The pizza was absolutely amazing. The Buffalo one was the best I've ever had, hands down! I definitely recommend giving their pizza a try! If we're ever upstate again, we'll definitely be back. Thanks!

S
Sergei C.

My daughter and i stop for pizza there almost everyday after school. We love it. Cooked just right and full of flavor. The people that help us are really friendly. The owner Sue is an amazing woman.

R
Rob M.

Great family run operation. Excellent pizza friendly people behind the counter nice place to hang out

A
Aloha K.

A really nice staff just delivered a spinach broccoli garlic calzone to my car when I stopped from the highway passing through to eat and it was good. Charged me a fair price of $10. I would recommend. Thanks for the good food. Chairman Emeritus Augustine

C
Chairman A.

Super friendly and nostalgic. Loved coming back here after all these years and it is still top notch !!!

T
Trevor

I've known the owners for over forty years, they are the best, they also make the best pizza around, you try it and you'll agree , we bought three large loaded pies, plus we traveled 15 minutes each way to get them. We could have bought them at several closer pizza places but opted for Marios, we will do it again. Simply the best.

C
Charles M.